Nightmare
5ED-184 · Fifth Edition · Rare
Nightmare is a Magic card from Fifth Edition, released March 24, 1997. This printing is Rare and carries a raw Near Mint market price of $1.26, updated throughout the week from live market data.
Listings
No active listings yet. The Near Mint market price is $1.26. List yours and you'll be the first. List this card →
Market activity
$1.26▲ 11.5% 100d
Market price · Near MintReference market price, updated Sep 15, 2026.
No active listings yet. Once stock appears, you’ll see price stats here.
Card details
- Series
- Core Set
- Card number
- #184
- Rarity
- Rare
- Released
- March 24, 1997
- Type
- Creature — Nightmare Horse
Format legality
historictimelessgladiatorpioneermodernlegacyvintagepennycommanderoathbreakerbrawlalchemydueloldschoolpremodernpredh
Other printings
The same card in other sets and rarities. Compare prices and pick the printing you want.
30th Anniversary Edition
$34.49
30th Anniversary Edition
$80.00
The List
$0.33
Welcome Deck 2017
$0.30
Welcome Deck 2016
$0.16
Magic Origins
$0.15
Magic 2015
$0.15
Magic 2014
$0.24
Magic 2010
$0.32
Tenth Edition
$0.37
Tenth Edition
Foil only
$0.37
Ninth Edition
$0.36
Ninth Edition
Foil only
$0.36
Eighth Edition
$0.44
Eighth Edition
Foil only
$0.44
Seventh Edition
$0.54
Seventh Edition
Foil only
$0.54
Classic Sixth Edition
$0.95
Fourth Edition
$2.06
Summer Magic / Edgar
—
Revised Edition
$7.60
Collectors' Edition
$17.75
Intl. Collectors' Edition
$22.77
Unlimited Edition
$94.81
More from Fifth Edition
- Mana Vault$97.26
- Necropotence$39.32
- Sylvan Library$29.24
- City of Brass$24.49
- Ashnod's Altar$15.64
- Game of Chaos$15.50
- Birds of Paradise$14.34
- Winter Orb$13.94
- Meekstone$12.81
- Armageddon$12.16
- Winds of Change$11.52
- Underground River$11.36